NFL-Style Pro Scouting Grading Sheet

This grading model mirrors how NFL scouts translate tape into actionable draft grades. It separates traits, assigns numerical values, and anchors grades to real roster outcomes. This format is publishable and defensible.

Universal 1–9 Trait Grade Scale

Grade
Meaning
NFL Translation
9.0
Rare / Elite
Immediate All-Pro
8.0
Outstanding
Year 1 Pro Bowl caliber
7.0
Very Good
High-end starter
6.5
Good
Solid starter
6.0
Adequate
Average starter / high-end role player
5.5
Marginal
Backup / spot starter
5.0
Below Average
Roster depth
4.5
Poor
Camp body
4.0
Replaceable
Practice squad

Position Trait Weighting Framework

Each position is graded on core traits. Final grade is the weighted average. Weights reflect real NFL priority—not college production.

QB

Processing, Accuracy, Pocket Movement, Decision-Making, Arm Talent

RB

Vision, Contact Balance, Burst, Pass Protection, Ball Security

WR

Separation, Route Detail, Hands, Release vs Press, YAC

TE

Functional Blocking, Route IQ, Hands, Versatility

OL

Footwork, Hand Usage, Balance, Anchor, Awareness

DL

Get-Off, Hand Violence, Leverage, Motor

EDGE

Pass Rush Plan, Burst, Power Conversion, Run Defense

LB

Key Reads, First Step, Angles, Coverage Ability

CB

Mirror Ability, Eyes, Ball Skills, Recovery Speed

S

Processing, Range, Angles, Tackling